Just busy and super-duper sleepy. If it weren't new-House-night, I'd be in bed already.
In my most recent testing news, my district has some f'd up standards (yes, I think my nod to profanity is warranted). And I don't mean content standards. Let me explain.
On Monday I administered my district's writing benchmark test. I get some leeway with it, so I wanted to front-load the rubric and all that. I copied the rubrics from the front cover and transferred them to overheads all in the 10 minutes before class (because the tests are kept under lock-and-key beforehand) because as a new teacher, I don't have a filing cabinet of all this stuff. So, there I am in front of my juniors and I unveil the rubric scale. It's a 6 level scale with some usual headings: Advanced, Proficient, Beginner -- I don't remember what-all -- oh, and Incompetent. Yes, the district is calling students who score a 1 "Incompetent". Not Emerging or Basic or even Below Basic. No. Incompetent.
Google "incompetent" (define: incompetent) and see what you find. I found definitions like "not qualified", "bungling", "unskilled" and my personal favorite, "not capable". Right, because we want to tell students that they are NOT CAPABLE of completing the assignments we give them. Not that they have a long way to go to become proficient (a reeeeeaaaaally long way, granted), but that they just can't do it.
Of course, the "Incompetent" students probably don't know what "incompetent" means, nor do they understand the finer points of language: like connotation. So, maybe it's OK. Except that in a district that is somewhere between 50% and 75% English Learners (many have been "exited" but will always carry an EL designation), many of my students are trying to succeed, but struggle with academic writing tasks. Should we berate our students for their faults, or bolster them in their attempts at growth? Hmmmm. I think I need to think on that one for a bit.
In my meeting today with other English teachers and my district's ELA support administrative whatever, I asked about this label. She was (rightfully) dismayed by the designation and went to check on it. Of course, neither she (nor the other English teachers) had ever, oh, NOTICED the use of the word on the FRONT PAGE of the test booklet. But, whatever. We're only English teachers. We don't need to do a close reading of anything.
Turns out, this rubric was taken DIRECTLY FROM THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA. Yup. Cali is labeling its lowest level students as incompetent. Something about that strikes me as, oh, classist? Racist? Prejudicist? Someist. Or maybe I don't need to coin a new word because "rude" works just fine. (I strive to make William Strunk, Jr. proud.)
One of these days, when I get a spare moment (maybe over Christmas break), I'm writing a letter to the peeps up in Sacramento. Because this s is totally f'd.
Family Visits
3 years ago